Just thought I would air my views on a subject recently taken my attention , Alsatian xs greys should they guard and all posses this trait, well here's my view based on experience of a good few of them, Ray has buck he don't seem to show inclination to be a guardian etc at the moment and things can and do change with given time.buck would not be the first of the xs that ain't particular about guarding etc most f1s in my experience have the mind set of the grey either ways they bred,for instance Jaz dam no guard jaz siblings all guard her half three quarter half brother guard he was one scary