Used both, Led lights are very good too, for what I intend on doing (filming) the H.I.D worked better, the spill is manageable with a very minor mod but its not really a problem. It actually has advantages if used correctly, but each to their own, I have had no problem with spill
by spill, I didn't mean it was a problem. These lamps are miles better than the LED, Iv used all three, halogen hid and LED and HID miles better in my opinion, even the dog has been catching better.
And it the spill on ANY lamp bothers u , u can buy a halo neoprene online that cuts it completely out