Blackman To Be Freed ....

[David.evans 5,323]

He would have bled out , if my radio , battery had died out. , oops

[greg64 3,062]

 

 

 

 

 

Well look it up joe berore you comment , and don't comment if you know fuc all about it

You and fecin Larry would get married ,pair of twats !

So i take it if an afghan shot a member of your family in the same way you would say "it's war" x

 

he was going to die anyway jo so I think he did the guy a favour

 

awful good of him, he might get a job in Nhs when he gets out

 

he would have bled out in the hospital corridor waiting for a doctor if the nhs were involved

 

i was thinking more for pain relief for the elderly

 

no your thinking of shipman not blackman

[Blackbriar 8,569]

Same result either way surely? Murder is murder in my eyes sorry if that offends anyone x

I'm not offended in the slightest.

 

But neither am I naive ! If you pick a fire fight with one of the world's elite military units, you can expect consequences......for me, it's THAT simple !

[Lab 10,979]

 

Same result either way surely? Murder is murder in my eyes sorry if that offends anyone x

I'm not offended in the slightest.

 

But neither am I naive ! If you pick a fire fight with one of the world's elite military units, you can expect consequences......for me, it's THAT simple !

What part of the law are you not getting.??

 

If a burglar broke into your house tonight and you caught him, tied him up and tortured him before stabbing him to death I'd agree with what you done but you know the law was going to f**k you right up.

No doubt plenty laws are needing changed..??

[walshie 2,804]

 

 

Same result either way surely? Murder is murder in my eyes sorry if that offends anyone x

I'm not offended in the slightest.

 

But neither am I naive ! If you pick a fire fight with one of the world's elite military units, you can expect consequences......for me, it's THAT simple !

What part of the law are you not getting.??

 

If a burglar broke into your house tonight and you caught him, tied him up and tortured him before stabbing him to death I'd agree with what you done but you know the law was going to f**k you right up.

No doubt plenty laws are needing changed..

 

 

Ah, but if he was sentenced, then served the time and got released, would you say he needed to go back in for longer?

[Blackbriar 8,569]

 

 

Same result either way surely? Murder is murder in my eyes sorry if that offends anyone x

I'm not offended in the slightest.

But neither am I naive ! If you pick a fire fight with one of the world's elite military units, you can expect consequences......for me, it's THAT simple !

What part of the law are you not getting.??

If a burglar broke into your house tonight and you caught him, tied him up and tortured him before stabbing him to death I'd agree with what you done but you know the law was going to f**k you right up.

No doubt plenty laws are needing changed..

Lab, i entirely "get" where Sgt. Blackman's detractors are coming from.......I just think they're wrong !

In an ordinary situation, I would probably agree with them - but this was a far from ordinary situation, so 'ordinary' rules shouldn't apply.

[BGD 6,437]

Has anyone on here actually said that he should go back in for longer?

 

I certainly didn't, in fact in my first post I said his sentence seemed about right considering his mental illness.

[dave88 1,565]

 

 

Has anyone on here actually said that he should go back in for longer?

 

I certainly didn't, in fact in my first post I said his sentence seemed about right considering his mental illness.

the mental illness was just oul bluff for the sympathy vote same as the regret

Where did you get your psychology degree may I ask?

[jacknife 2,005]

At the end of the day the law saw sence and he has the backing of millions of British people

 

No one really cares what those think who would have rather the taliban fighter received the best medical care so he could return to his country to rape or even carry out a Westminster style attack

[Blackbriar 8,569]

 

 

Same result either way surely? Murder is murder in my eyes sorry if that offends anyone x

I'm not offended in the slightest.

But neither am I naive ! If you pick a fire fight with one of the world's elite military units, you can expect consequences.....for me, it's THAT simple !

Same if you murder someone i guess x

I'm not being pedantic, but i don't see your point....

[Lab 10,979]

 

 

 

 

Same result either way surely? Murder is murder in my eyes sorry if that offends anyone x

I'm not offended in the slightest.

 

But neither am I naive ! If you pick a fire fight with one of the world's elite military units, you can expect consequences......for me, it's THAT simple !

What part of the law are you not getting.??

 

If a burglar broke into your house tonight and you caught him, tied him up and tortured him before stabbing him to death I'd agree with what you done but you know the law was going to f**k you right up.

No doubt plenty laws are needing changed..

Ah, but if he was sentenced, then served the time and got released, would you say he needed to go back in for longer?

If he has done the time then that's it. Whatever the judge says he should do he must do it and get on with it.

It's a shite position to be in but he put himself in it.

Been thinking more about it and at purely a guess I say some of the army lads that don't condone his actions might be pissed off that he has done it and they have had to hold back.

So if he was to walk away scot free I can see the rule book being thrown out th window.

[Born Hunter 17,960]

 

At the end of the day the law saw sence and he has the backing of millions of British people

No one really cares what those think who would have rather the taliban fighter received the best medical care so he could return to his country to rape or even carry out a Westminster style attack

Do you know what the Geneva convention is? x

 

 

Do you?

 

You do realise he wasn't prosecuted for breaking the GC right?

[jacknife 2,005]

 

At the end of the day the law saw sence and he has the backing of millions of British people

No one really cares what those think who would have rather the taliban fighter received the best medical care so he could return to his country to rape or even carry out a Westminster style attack

Do you know what the Geneva convention is? x

Yes it something that doesn't always work in real life situation

 

Its also something that if strictly adhered to could be the difference between wining and loosing

 

Do you think the likes of the taliban or the Russians give a shit about it

[Lab 10,979]

 

 

 

Same result either way surely? Murder is murder in my eyes sorry if that offends anyone x

I'm not offended in the slightest.

But neither am I naive ! If you pick a fire fight with one of the world's elite military units, you can expect consequences......for me, it's THAT simple !

What part of the law are you not getting.??

If a burglar broke into your house tonight and you caught him, tied him up and tortured him before stabbing him to death I'd agree with what you done but you know the law was going to f**k you right up.

No doubt plenty laws are needing changed..

Lab, i entirely "get" where Sgt. Blackman's detractors are coming from.......I just think they're wrong !

In an ordinary situation, I would probably agree with them - but this was a far from ordinary situation, so 'ordinary' rules shouldn't apply.

I'm afraid it is an ordinary situation on a 'battlefield'. That's what the signed up to I'm afraid.

If you however asked me to vote on changing those rules I would.

[Silversnake 1,099]

 

 

Same result either way surely? Murder is murder in my eyes sorry if that offends anyone x

I'm not offended in the slightest.

 

But neither am I naive ! If you pick a fire fight with one of the world's elite military units, you can expect consequences......for me, it's THAT simple !

What part of the law are you not getting.??

 

If a burglar broke into your house tonight and you caught him, tied him up and tortured him before stabbing him to death I'd agree with what you done but you know the law was going to f**k you right up.

No doubt plenty laws are needing changed..??

But laws will never change if people don't express their outrage when laws are needing changing...