the dunkeld is over-rated....very! the greenwells is the most perfect wet ever devized and i have used it extensively......the simplicity of it is its key and when tied in a correct and clinical manner they look very very nice....its not the biggest or the brightest flies that take the most skill, but those that require a nice, even tight wing....with nothing to hide any imperfections... ...IMHO it is a fly that cannot be improved upon for the northern trout streams in may...save perhaps for the partridge and orange..... but then again, neatness and perfection, i feel, is of little note to