dotty , there'll be lots of answers to this topic ?? but is there a right or wrong answer , every breeder breeds for THEIR reasons nobody elses , i see no difference if the pups are sold or given away for free --- the only opinion i'd say is , if theyre free , the breeder is more likely to let any tom dick or asshole have one , where as if theyre for sale , it's only good honest people wanting them , yes i know you could get assholes wanting to buy too , but the free option i think theres more likely they'd be let go------just my opinion thoug ----den