Jump to content

Recommended Posts

A pal of mine sent me an extract from Sporting Gun magazine where they interview Dr Mark Avery of Wild Justice fame. In the interview, MA states that they have made a challenge on the legality of the new GL26, carrion crows, as it refers to culling of carrion crows in relation to the protection of pheasants. The issue is that WJ believe that reared pheasants cannot be regarded as livestock as they are wild birds. I am not going to try to capture the entire article but it made interesting reading.

It is very clear from the comments made by Dr Avery that WJ are going to be on the case with every aspect of the new general licenses to the point that in my humble opinion, this whole process despite defra taking over, will be delayed by quite some time.

In order to allow the farming community to have full crop protection this year, I strongly believe they should revert back to the three GL's until the end of the year and have the time to consult with WJ, basc, nfu etc etc in order to bring a new GL to satisfy all parties. Interestingly, MA said that NE have had no further discussion regarding the details of the new GL which is madness not to include all parties concerned.

I don't know how to post the interview sent to me for you all to read but I will try to work out how to do it or of course buy a copy of Sporting Gun.

Phil

Share this post


Link to post

https://www.birdguides.com/news/wild-justice-launches-new-legal-challenge/

 

Questions Sporting Gun asked Dr Mark Avery on Monday 10 June 2019 following the latest legal challenge to general licences from Wild Justice, the wildlife campaign group that includes Dr Avery, Chris Packham, the TV presenter and naturalist, and Dr Ruth Tingay, the conservationist.

Seven weeks after Natural England revoked the general licences GL04, GL05 and GL06 on April 25, following a legal challenge from Wild Justice, the wildlife campaign group has submitted a further challenge.
This latest legal challenge has arrived while the shooting and farming world is still waiting for Defra and Natural England to decide on a permanent solution to the issue of the licences. In the meantime, Natural England has issued three new licences – GL26, GL28 and GL31. It is the new licence GL26 that Wild Justice is challenging the legality of through its solicitors, Leigh Day. In particular, it is focusing on the culling of carrion crows in relation to the protection of pheasants.
The nub of the issue relates to the interpretation as to whether pheasants are regarded as livestock or wild birds and whether, if the former, shooters have the right to cull carrion crows to protect their livestock.
It is an issue with many implications and we asked Dr Mark Avery of Wild Justice a number of questions relating to its latest challenge. Here are his answers in full:

Sporting Gun: You say that you would like Natural England to reflect on the legality of GL26 but surely that is what they have done by revoking the previous licences and issuing the new ones?

Mark Avery: Yes, but we think they’ve got them wrong – again. We ask Natural England, and Defra, to get this right in these and other forthcoming licences. But we ask them to remove the elements of GL26 that refer to gamebirds and start again. Maybe we need that full consultation to get this right. By the way, Natural England and Defra have not spoken to us about these matters.

SG: Your letter takes issue with the legal interpretation of ‘kept’ and that many birds that are currently regarded as being so are in fact wild and therefore not ‘kept’. How would you apply this interpretation to other livestock in view of Leigh Day’s definition of “free-living”, especially with regard to, say, ‘hefted’ sheep in Cumbria and how does that differ from your view of how pheasants are ‘kept’?

MA: Not quite – we think that Natural England have gone out on a limb with an unlawful definition of ‘kept’. We’ve never heard anyone claim that a pheasant in a field, or running about on the road causing accidents, is livestock because it might nip back for a couple of pecks of grain now and again. If your sheep is in my garden then I can probably have a good guess at who owns it and phone you up. If your pheasant is in my garden how do I complain to you about your livestock’s eating of my vegetables? If it’s livestock then we believe that the owner is responsible for it. Did Natural England dream this up on their own or were they pressured by shooting interests? And whichever it was, was this really a good idea?

SG: With regard to the purpose of control under the general licence, how would you propose that a legally practicable way of determining whether there were no alternatives to ‘lethal killing’ be implemented and enforced?

MA: We’re not sure. That’s Natural England’s job. We don’t want to do their job – but we do want them to do it properly. Natural England haven’t sought to speak to us about any of this – we believe they’ve had lots of chats with other organisations.

SG: Do you think your challenge will help focus Natural England and clarify matters for people who shoot to enable them to carry on doing so or is your ultimate goal to outlaw all shooting of game birds for sport?

 MA: We aren’t trying to outlaw all shooting of gamebirds for sport, and if we were, this would be a very tortuous route. We are pretty sure that game shooting will continue for a very, very long time. But we do think that shooting needs to be better conducted in many regards. Recreational shooting of wildlife has not done a good job through self-regulation and we want Natural England to do its job in acting as a fair but firm regulator.

Lead shot should be replaced by non-toxic ammunition, stocking densities in release areas should be reduced to the levels of good practice suggested by the Game and Wildlife Conservation Trust, illegal persecution of birds of prey should cease, the numbers of released gamebirds should be greatly reduced and lethal control of native predators should be directed at the appropriate species (certainly not Jay, Jackdaw, Rook and Magpie) by appropriate means. These are things that we often hear sensible shooters say but we see little progress on the ground. And if they all happened tomorrow then shooting would still be happening.

SG: In Wild Justice’s latest legal challenge to Natural England it focuses on the rearing of game (particularly pheasants). You seem to be targeting the shooting community. By singling out a small section of society (shooters) is this a cynical divide and conquer tactic?

MA: We feel shooting is very unregulated whereas farming is quite strongly regulated. There are things we don’t like about the licences already published and the parts of them that relate to farming, but we feel that these could probably be addressed through a review and consultation. It was, presumably, Natural England’s decision to link game rearing and sheep and piglets together in one licence. This may be because of extreme pressure on Natural England from shooting interests. Natural England don’t actually mention any evidence that carrion crows are a problem for game during the period before they are released! A consequence of that is that GL26 is under scrutiny from us for a variety of reasons. You are right to identify the fact that the interests of farming and shooting may not always and exactly coincide.

SG: Through your challenges of the general licences what do you want to achieve? Is it biodiversity, or something else?

MA: We want public bodies to implement the laws protecting wildlife properly – that is a fundamental part of nature conservation but also of the legal system. Shooting and farming interests exert massive pressure on the likes of Natural England in an attempt to get their way with things and they don’t always have wildlife at the front of their minds. Carrion crows can’t speak up for themselves and we are very happy to take up their cases for them.

SG: What’s next on the agenda for Wild Justice and when do you think you will have achieved your goals?

MA: We expect to be quite busy with general licences for a while. We can’t see that issue going away and we are interested to see what Defra comes up with – whatever it is, it’s overdue. We have taken legal advice about beaver culls in Scotland, though …

Share this post


Link to post

Well done Chris and thank you, I'm rubbish at this sort of thing.

Phil

Share this post


Link to post

I just copied it from the Pigeonwatch forum. Worth taking a look at their discussions on everything to do with the GLs at present as some good points raised. Also Verminbashers on FB do have some good input (and unfortunately not so good ones i.e. 'those who well I'm going to carry on regardless and post everything' brigrade.

The shooter's 3 S's : Shoot, Shovel and Shut-up

  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post

Quote  :-         'The shooter's 3 S's : Shoot, Shovel and Shut-up'

Sound advice Chris, like it.

Phil

Share this post


Link to post

very good

Share this post


Link to post

Ive just had a look at the article phil and its very clear that this battle is going to be very hard to win because the people behind all these opposals are clearly as thick as shit and have absolutely no idea whatsoever what it is they are talking about. They are just jumping on the eco bandwagon without considering all of the consequences to their stupid, unqualified actions. They simply cant have spent more than 5 minutes out in the woods or down a hedgerow with their eyes open to have noticed crows and maggies scanning the hedge for the nests of the very birds that ARE protected with no licence to kill them,  ie finches, blackbirds  robins etc.

These idiots will be calling for the ban on swatting fruit flies because at the end of the day, what harm are they doing????

I cannot belive these simpletons are allowed a voice, its a wonder they can wipe their own arses🤬🤬

  • Like 3
  • Thanks 2

Share this post


Link to post

I'm applying for a couple of cover licences as im sick of waiting for them to sort this out and I can't see them doing it any time soon:censored:

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post

I know what you are saying Si but I am not keen on the idea as I would need about 7 and what a load of hassle as well as telling NE or whoever where all my shooting is and I do not trust NE at all with the total cock up they have made, I am not so sure I want to give them very much information.

Phil

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post

this is basically a break down of that interview for people like me who are sick of reading the sh1t:thumbs:

 

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
1 minute ago, philpot said:

I know what you are saying Si but I am not keen on the idea as I would need about 7 and what a load of hassle as well as telling NE or whoever where all my shooting is and I do not trust NE at all with the total cock up they have made, I am not so sure I want to give them very much information.

Phil

to tell you the truth Phil... I've got to keep every thing above board as you've met one of the Avery fan club last time you were up here!!

all ive got to do is film where im applying for and there's no way that they can come back from it...

all I think is fcukit, ill play the game if that's what they want!

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post

 Mind you from what I have heard it will take ages to get one as they have been bombarded with requests and are way behind. Yes that guy had already made his mind up, pity he didn't get the bloke with the dog.

 

Phil

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
53 minutes ago, philpot said:

 Mind you from what I have heard it will take ages to get one as they have been bombarded with requests and are way behind. Yes that guy had already made his mind up, pity he didn't get the bloke with the dog.

 

Phil

I should of invited him to have ago of the side by side

:whistling:

 

 

 

O sorry officer i should of told you DONT PULL THE FRONT TRIGGER FIRST

:yahoo::yahoo::yahoo:

ATVBJIMMY:thumbs::thumbs::thumbs:

  • Haha 3

Share this post


Link to post

I know loads are going to carry on shooting pigeons and crows from now on 

just typical of this government since May has bee in charge . She has fcuked up everything by bowing down to the lefty scum and that includes some in the same Tory party of hers 

Share this post


Link to post
9 minutes ago, villaman said:

I know loads are going to carry on shooting pigeons and crows from now on 

just typical of this government since May has bee in charge . She has fcuked up everything by bowing down to the lefty scum and that includes some in the same Tory party of hers 

Who’d do a better job then v’man? 😁

Share this post


Link to post

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×