Jump to content

Judges for 25th Annual All Ireland Terrier & Lurcher Champonships


Recommended Posts


  • Replies 30
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Posts

Albert you don't know me so I hope you don't find me cheeky in what I am asking,I know that through your excellent game fairs much needed money is raised for very needy charities and for that I take m

I've worked dogs for over 45 years, and judged quite a few shows... do you REALY think people know what I, or other judges have done ? I'ts a dog show ffs !! I'ts not Crufts !! Have a day out, show yo

Any judge can only judge what's in the ring on the day. You will never be able to assess if a dog can work or not. As a judge you have to have in your minds eye what you would want in a dog that is fi

He keeps and races whippets.

how can he judge a working whippet.

 

We think it is best to put judges names up in advance of the show and not surprise people on the day. If someone has a particular problem with a judge they can choose as to whether to bring a dog to show under him or her. For our 25th All Ireland and 50th Game Fair we have chosen to bring judges in from Scotland to try to avoid the criticism that is often levelled against local juges. They are all fresh faces and so I would suggest as Den says see how they judge before making any comments.

 

You have posed the question about the whippet judge about how he could judge a working whippet - Before I answer this question perhaps you would share with us your opinion of what a working whippet looks like?

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

I haven't met the man, but I would assume that if he races Whippets with any degree of success, he knows his way around a Whippet, wether Racer, Worker or shower. :thumbs:

 

Cheers.

cheers ritchie, i'm sure leigh will do a styerling job

Link to post
Share on other sites

I haven't met the man, but I would assume that if he races Whippets with any degree of success, he knows his way around a Whippet, wether Racer, Worker or shower. :thumbs:

 

Cheers.

cheers ritchie, i'm sure leigh will do a styerling job

 

I judged the Whippets at Birr a couple of years ago, Den, was one of the best times I've had !! Fishing in the Grand Canal, drinking with the good people of Ballycommon, and meeting so many dog men and women and class dogs at the show !! A great experience ! :thumbs:

 

Cheers.

Link to post
Share on other sites

He keeps and races whippets.

how can he judge a working whippet.

 

We think it is best to put judges names up in advance of the show and not surprise people on the day. If someone has a particular problem with a judge they can choose as to whether to bring a dog to show under him or her. For our 25th All Ireland and 50th Game Fair we have chosen to bring judges in from Scotland to try to avoid the criticism that is often levelled against local juges. They are all fresh faces and so I would suggest as Den says see how they judge before making any comments.

 

You have posed the question about the whippet judge about how he could judge a working whippet - Before I answer this question perhaps you would share with us your opinion of what a working whippet looks like?

its the same in the lamping class for the lurchers how can they judge one when they have never worked one.
Link to post
Share on other sites

I haven't met the man, but I would assume that if he races Whippets with any degree of success, he knows his way around a Whippet, wether Racer, Worker or shower. :thumbs:

 

Cheers.

i dont know the man hope that he will do a good job.but i think they should bring in working judges they would get a better crowd.
Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest ladyjane

Any judge can only judge what's in the ring on the day. You will never be able to assess if a dog can work or not. As a judge you have to have in your minds eye what you would want in a dog that is fit for purpose, and every judge will differ, that's what a show is about, one persons opinion!

 

  • Like 2
Link to post
Share on other sites

I haven't met the man, but I would assume that if he races Whippets with any degree of success, he knows his way around a Whippet, wether Racer, Worker or shower. :thumbs:

 

Cheers.

i dont know the man hope that he will do a good job.but i think they should bring in working judges they would get a better crowd.

 

I've worked dogs for over 45 years, and judged quite a few shows... do you REALY think people know what I, or other judges have done ? I'ts a dog show ffs !! I'ts not Crufts !! Have a day out, show your dogs, and have the good grace to congratulate the winners and thank the judges !! Judging is a thankless job, but we do it because we love dogs, and there wouldn't be a show without a judge !!

 

Cheers.

Edited by chartpolski
  • Like 3
Link to post
Share on other sites

I haven't met the man, but I would assume that if he races Whippets with any degree of success, he knows his way around a Whippet, wether Racer, Worker or shower. :thumbs:

 

Cheers.

i dont know the man hope that he will do a good job.but i think they should bring in working judges they would get a better crowd.

 

Twiggy,

 

As someone who has worked his dogs (both working and show bred) and has had their work assessed having won with my dogs in actual trials and tests and at the highest level in the showring AND who judges I really would not want to show a dog under someone whose only qualification was ' he works his dogs'. That is not a qualification for judging - it may not even be an assessment that the person is competent to train a dog for work. To judge a show and it is a show NOT a working test one must have a good idea of conformation fit for purpose, overall condition & fitness, movement, balance and how to go over a dog. They must have some idea in their mind of what the ideal dog is they are judging the dogs in front of them against. Now you haven't answered my question - what do you think a working whippet should look like?

 

Albertj

  • Like 1
Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

  • Similar Content

    • By appleblossom
      Please note the IWTF Show advertised for this Sunday 10th August at Slane was cancelled a month ago , but will be back again in 2026.   Margaret McStay      
    • By appleblossom
      The Burren Charity Working Dog Show and Raceday Saturday 26th July 25   From the Pen of Margaret Mc Stay   As the clock on the wall jingled out its usual dulcet tones on Saturday morning, it signalled the start of a new day for us and another great sporting event on our country sports calendar. With Mrs Sat Nav being our guiding light along the way, and the beautiful Mourne Mountains following us enroute, very soon The Burren came into view and the dog show venue for the day. And what a venue that was. It was evident the amount of hard work the Burren Team had put into this show ground. It was in tiptop condition with six toilets on site, rings well spaced out and a superb racetrack with a very steep hill. And what a tester for our dogs this track was. With the sun shining down all day in abundance and a very large gathering of canine folk from North and South of the border, the atmosphere was electric. I can honestly say this was the biggest show I have been at this year and all for a great charity. As the day progressed I took a stroll around the many stands dotted around the field. I stopped of at Mick Mc Cormacks stand. Mick and Lorna are always so welcoming and have a stand full of everything for the hunting fraternity. Next door was flight & bite Outdoor Clothing & Footwear. I had a great we chat with owner Richard Caddell. Richard and I go back a very long time from our times at The Great Games Fairs of Ireland at Shanes Castle. I think most of our outdoor gear for dog shows were bought of this man over the years. You would not go hungry at this show. Burgers/Drinks/ Snacks/Teas and coffee were all available on site. The children had a field day with a child handling class. Every child got a medal and a bag full of goodies. With their barking and crooning canine friends by their sides, these little people were in their happy place and full of winning spirit As the day progressed into evening, it was raffle time and then the excitement began. It is unbelievable the buzz of excitement the raffle generates to the people around the ring. There were some great items in the raffle, and some very happy campers going home with great prizes The Racing started at approximately 12 noon followed by Showing. Here are the Racing and Showing Results: ***Racing Results*** Pups Kieran with Jimmy Kirsty with Sika Whippet James Mullen with Junior James Mullen with Toby Under 21s Lynzi Gardiner Magill with Bill Rose Mc Coy with Arlo Under 22s Lynzi Gardiner Magill with Venus Rose Mc Coy with Texas Under 23 elite Lynzi Gardiner Magill with Lady Lynzi Gardiner Magill with Cody Under 23s traditional lurcher Mj with Lila Under 24 smooth Lynzi Gardiner Magill with Jack Rose Mc Coy with Prada Under 24 hairy Harry Roche with Sula Joyce Scott with Susan Master McGrath Jake with Storm Joyce Scott with Guss Mick the Miller Jed Donagh with Chaz Lynzi Gardiner Magill with Sugar Light bull Yapper Hayes with Lady Leigh Thompson with Roxy Heavy bull Joyce Scott with Mable Leigh Thompson with King Terrier Matthew Wisdom with Rocco Elaine with Ruby Greyhounds Barry Holland with Hunter ***Showing Results*** Overall Champion Pup Clodagh Gentle with Dash Overall Champion Whippet James Mullen with Toby Overall Champion Lurcher Shane Burns with Buster Overall Champion Terrier Marty Mc Donald with Rebel Overall Champion Strong Dog Chris Mc Court with Sandy Overall Champion Hound Iveaghs Grapevine Overall Champion and Best in Show Marty Mc Donald with Rebel Overall Champion Reserve Chris Mc Court with Sandy Congratulations to all above winners and well done. And Finally, may I take this opportunity to thank the judges on the day, for doing a wonderful job.The Judging was delivered with accuracy and integrity, and a job was well done by all. A special word of thanks to these legends in the Doggie world yes The Mc Grath Dog Racing Club Carlow. Again this year Biddy, you and the boys, and you as a team excelled yourselves in everything you done on the day for the Burren Working Dog Charity Show and Club and many thanks for that. You have been so helpful to so many clubs North and South of the border over the years and long may it last. Finally, Finally this top show would not of been possible without this now well experienced and brilliant show organiser. Yes, I would like to thank the coordinator of this spectacular charity event Stephen Mc Nally and his family, Dad Louis, mother Margaret, brothers Martin and Noel, sister Theresa, Philip Mackin, and a most willing, helpful and friendly back up team and helpers for another top charity show and race day. A light went out in the Mc Nally household, when Stephen and his family lost a son and a beloved brother to cancer. This is total heart break for any family, but Stephens reason and inspiration behind the Burren Charity Working Dog Shows is to keep the memory of his brother alive through giving back to the charities, through his dog shows to the people who helped the family in their hour of need. This years chosen charity “Daisy Lodge Cancer Fund For Children “ is a charity that makes a real difference in the lives of families affected by cancer. Their mission is to empower and connect families, giving them the support they need to cope with the emotional and practical challenges of a cancer diagnosis. They also stand beside bereaved families, offering care and guidance to those grieving the loss of a child or parent. This is where your gate, racing, ring and raffle contribution to The Burren Charity Working Dog Show will go to, and what a very worthy cause. For that we truly thank you for your contribution. Thanks to Stephen and the Burren Team for a most enjoyable day, for the kindness you have shown to John and myself on the day. A brilliant venue and a brilliant day full of lovely memories, and I am already looking forward to more of the same god willing in 2026. To we meet again God Bless. Margaret Mc Stay
    • By appleblossom
      The Keep er Lit Dog Show and Raceday Sunday 20th July 2025
      Doagh Equestrian is situated on the beautiful Antrim coast in the village of Doagh, Co Antrim. This was a new venue for the “Keep er Lit” Dog show and Race day and the ideal spot for   last Sundays Show.  
      From early morning, cars and trailers arrived from North and South of the border. Some people came as far away as Limerick and Drogheda with families and dogs in tow. Our good canine folk love a good dog show in the summer and a chat with like minded people. They certainly were not disappointed at the Keep er Lit show.  
      As the show progressed, so did the banter and the craic. The rings were well spaced out with a good long race track. Paul Boyd was there with his country sports stand, with everything needed in the hunting fraternity. 
      Some very tasty burgers were available on site and an Equestrian shop with great discounts on offer on the day. I had to take control of my retail therapy when I got into that shop, as I was like a child in a toy shop with to much to choose from.
      The weather was glorious all day and at times to warm. As usual the raffle generated a great buzz around the field with some great prizes on offer. 
      The show started with the racing first at approximately 12.30 
      Here are the Racing and Showing Results 
      Racing Results from the Pen of Biddy Mc Grath
      Whippets
      Fred Gentle with Clive
      Fred Gentle with Susie
      Under 21s
      Lynzi Gardiner Magill with Bill
      Rose Mc Coy with Arlo
      Under 22s 
      Lynzi Gardiner Magill with Ruby
      Rose Mc Coy with Texas
      Under 23s 
      Kirby-Jane Mc Kibben with Shiba 
      Lynzi Gardiner Magill with Cody
      Under 24 smooth 
      Lynzi Gardiner Magill with Jack 
      Rose Mc Coy with Prada 
      Under 24 Hairy 
      Jed Donagh with Tess 
      Matthew with Rebel 
      Bullcross Light
      Yapper Hayes with Lady
      Joyce Scott with Axle
      Bullcross Heavy 
      Joyce Scott with Mable
      Matthew with Willow 
      Pups 
      Lewis Lyons with Rex
      Gadgie with Sport 
      Greyhound 
      Barry Holland with Hunter 
      Katelyn Mc Kenzie with Luna 
      Mick the Miller 
      Jed Donagh with Chance
      Lynzi Gardiner Magill with Sugar 
      Master Mc Grath Qualifer
      Paul Owens with King 
      Jack Townsend with Xara
      Showing Results from the Pen of Leigh Thompson
      Overall Champion Lurcher 
      Ged Donagh with Shea
      Reserve 
      Lisa Beggs with Rossa
      Overall Champion Whippet
      Karla Wilson with Junior
      Reserve 
      John Shaw with Blue
      Overall Champion Terrier
      Kenny Hamilton with Ned
      Reserve 
      Ged Donagh with Pip.
      Overall Champion Pet
      Jackie with Frost
      Reserve 
      Michelle Wendt with Harry
      Overall Strong Dog Champion 
      Franky Corrigan with Prada 
      Reserve 
      Graham Ryan with Winnie
      Overall Show Champion and Best in Show
      Ged Donagh with Shea
      Reserve Overall Show Champion
      Franky Corrigan with Prada
      Overall Puppy Champion
      Graham Ryan with Celt
      Congratulations to all above winners.
      And Finally, may I take this opportunity to thank the judges and their ring stewards on the day,on behalf of the Keep er Lit Team for a job well done.
      Strong Dog Judge : Gareth Barnett
      Lurcher Judge       : Gerard Melaugh
      Whippet Judge      : Colin Maguire
      Terrier Judge         : Martin Breen
      Pets Judge             : Gail Ross
      Judging is not an easy job, but you were consistent and fair, and very successful with the end product. 
      The racing was carried out as usual to perfection by The Mc Grath Racing Club Carlow. These people have many years experience in the Canine world both in showing and racing and their input helps to alleviate the pressure on the show organizer on the day. A job well done Biddy and team. 
      Some lovely photographs were taken on the day by various people, and no doubt these will be up on the site shortly.
      And Finally, Finally, they say behind every good man is a good woman and Leigh Thompson along with Paddy Gibson, you both definitely fitted into that category. Your show was run with impeccable organisation. It was evident on the day a lot of hard work and sleepless nights was put into  this now annual Show. Leigh and Paddy you pulled out all the stops on the day and produced a top class show in a top class venue. Well done and a credit to you both.
      I am Looking forward to more of the same in 2026. Thank you for the memories.To we meet again God Bless.
        
       Margaret Mc Stay
       
       
    • By appleblossom
      FROM THE PEN OF MARGARET MC STAY   ****RIGHT FOLKS UPWARDS AND ONWARDS.****   ANOTHER TOP SHOW THIS WEEKEND.   ALL ROADS LEAD TO THE BURREN DOG SHOW AND RACEDAY THIS SATURDAY 26th JULY 2025. FOLKS THIS SHOW IS A CHARITY SHOW IN AID OF DAISY LODGE CANCER FUND FOR CHILDREN AND ALL PROCEEDS FROM THE DAY GOES TO THIS SPECIAL CHARITY.   ****REMEMBER EVERY PENNY YOU CONTRIBUTE TO THIS VERY SPECIAL SHOW AND CAUSE ON THE DAY , HELPS MAKE SOME LITTLE ONE SOMEWHERE VERY COMFORTABLE IN THEIR HOUR OF NEED.****   HOPE TO SEE YOU ALL THERE     FOR YOUR SAT NAVS:   Greenan Road   Newry   BT34 2PT   Margaret Mc Stay

×
×
  • Create New...