While I agree with much of what you say Onan, I would like to hear the views of a hunting type lifeboat man/woman.
I don't think they need bringing up to scratch or being non-voluntary. There is never a shortage of crews, and many people are very grateful for the attendance of these brave folks. Just ensure they all have a good boat and safety kit, and leave them to get on with it,I would say.
and chuck 'em a couple of quid a week each, and make sure that they're allowed to have dogs work with them. didnt like it when that newfoundland (i think) had to stop