Jump to content
Sign in to follow this  
olivhar01

3" or 3.5"

Recommended Posts

im off to buy a new semi-auto this week for wildfowling and pigeon shooting. any advice would be good on a 3" or 3.5" chamber

 

cheers

cal

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Guest 8 Bore

im off to buy a new semi-auto this week for wildfowling and pigeon shooting. any advice would be good on a 3" or 3.5" chamber

 

cheers

cal

 

Which gun are you thinking about?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

im off to buy a new semi-auto this week for wildfowling and pigeon shooting. any advice would be good on a 3" or 3.5" chamber

 

cheers

cal

 

Which gun are you thinking about?

 

open to options really. this will be my first semi auto

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

HI mate I have one thing to say on the choice of SA shotguns,BENELLI,BENELLI, BENELLI,ok i know thats three things but if you can afford one GET 1, ive had my M1for 5 years now and can say honestly it has never jammed NOT ONCE,if you get a black or cammo synthetic ,the rust proofing coating on the barrel is very good I use mine for lots of coastal wildfowling, so understand what saltwater can do to a gun, in a v short space of time, get an M1 M2 OR SUPER BLACK EAGLE, you will not regret it,whatever you do do not buy an escort/hatsan they are garbage, with SA shotguns you get what you pay for,and as for 3 or 3.5 dont worry to much Ihave used both and personaly i prefer 3 inch,you should not shoot at geese over 40 yds and the longer ones only hold a tiny bit more shot(sometimes the sameor less)so why pay extra for a gimicky cartrige, also when you shoot normal shells you will not get patterns as good as the 3 inch gun cos of the vlong chambers, warm barrels

 

CHARLIE CALLER

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

HI mate I have one thing to say on the choice of SA shotguns,BENELLI,BENELLI, BENELLI,ok i know thats three things but if you can afford one GET 1, ive had my M1for 5 years now and can say honestly it has never jammed NOT ONCE,if you get a black or cammo synthetic ,the rust proofing coating on the barrel is very good I use mine for lots of coastal wildfowling, so understand what saltwater can do to a gun, in a v short space of time, get an M1 M2 OR SUPER BLACK EAGLE, you will not regret it,whatever you do do not buy an escort/hatsan they are garbage, with SA shotguns you get what you pay for,and as for 3 or 3.5 dont worry to much Ihave used both and personaly i prefer 3 inch,you should not shoot at geese over 40 yds and the longer ones only hold a tiny bit more shot(sometimes the sameor less)so why pay extra for a gimicky cartrige, also when you shoot normal shells you will not get patterns as good as the 3 inch gun cos of the vlong chambers, warm barrels

 

CHARLIE CALLER

 

hi charlie caller

thanks for the advice on this as i went to the local gunshop this week and they stock the hatson escort and told me that i could not go wrong with one?? ive not decided on one and need advice hence the post. i will only be using it for duck, pigeon and occasional geese. im not new to wildfowling just new to semi autos

Edited by olivhar01

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've heard a few bad reports on Hatson - jamming, but thats probably just people who don't clean them regular !.

 

I'd spend a little more if you can afford - the Winchester Super X3 is 3.5inch and is an excellent gun. If you read the net you will find most reviews on this gun are top notch ! Give Malmo guns a call, this usually stock it.

 

The gun comes with stock spacers. Shims are also provided for drop and cast adjustment.

 

2048428478_08216a68a8.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

No experience of the Hatsan myself but, over on the wildfowling forum, there certainly seems to be a number of people who agree with Laurona 12 and reckon that it is false economy to go for a cheapie semi-auto. Benneli, Beretta and Winchester seems to be the favourites.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Mossberg 935 magnum will take a 3.5 cart and come in various barrel lengths aswell.

 

Also comes with a sling and in camo or black synthetic. I paid £580 for my cammo one, but you can get the black synthetic for around £400.

 

The most important thing is to see what fits you best really

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I repeat, do not buy an escort mate you will regret it I have a mate who bought one and while i admit he could shoot with it,the damn thing jammed from day one and he cleaned it religiously,and ive heard loads of similar stories,chances are few in wildfowling and when youve frozen all morning in your muddy hole the last thing you want is your gun to fail as the only chance of the flight comes over,benelli come with shims and spacers, so you can fit the gun to yourself,they operate on inertia not a gas piston, and thats why they are so reliable,yes they are quite expensive but if you look after them they will last a lifetime,get a 3" m1 or m2 and you can shoot everything from woodies to geese to foxes with confidence,and of course use steel in them, the only time i use steel is to shoot woodies for my hawk to eat, for duck ect tungsten or heavy shot is the best,and before anyone asks no i dont work for benelli lol,(wish i did)take my advice mate forget the rest buy the best. cheers CHARLIE CALLER.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

the mossberd 935 is a magnum gun and will be no use for duck or pigeon,unless you want them well tenderised blasting them with magnum shells. ive heard they are a good gun but i think the gun hes after is an all rounder which will cost you money for a decent one,dont forget to add browning to your list, ive got a gold hunter and its pretty much faultless keep them clean and well lokked after and you wont have any problems

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've heard a few bad reports on Hatson - jamming, but thats probably just people who don't clean them regular !.

 

I'd spend a little more if you can afford - the Winchester Super X3 is 3.5inch and is an excellent gun. If you read the net you will find most reviews on this gun are top notch ! Give Malmo guns a call, this usually stock it.

 

The gun comes with stock spacers. Shims are also provided for drop and cast adjustment.

 

2048428478_08216a68a8.jpg

 

laurona12

thanks for the reply, have read some good reviews but struggling to find one in shadowgrass camo, a popular gun it seems

 

ATB

Cal

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have both a Benelli and a Winchester Super X3. I tend though to pick up the X3 first.

Both of mine are 3.5" so they can both handle any length of cartridge. They do however do them both in 3"?

The Benelli is Wetlands and the Super X3 is Mossy Oak Duck Blind. I believe that and Advantage Timber are the only two camo available in the X3?

 

 

4115490066_a64c436bf0.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I've heard a few bad reports on Hatson - jamming, but thats probably just people who don't clean them regular !.

 

I'd spend a little more if you can afford - the Winchester Super X3 is 3.5inch and is an excellent gun. If you read the net you will find most reviews on this gun are top notch ! Give Malmo guns a call, this usually stock it.

 

The gun comes with stock spacers. Shims are also provided for drop and cast adjustment.

 

2048428478_08216a68a8.jpg

 

laurona12

thanks for the reply, have read some good reviews but struggling to find one in shadowgrass camo, a popular gun it seems

 

ATB

Cal

I think Malmo Guns would get you one to order. I also think Swillington Shooting Supplies can also get them.

 

Cheers

L12

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Have to agree with the Benelli, I have a synthetic Super Black Eagle 3.5" and its just so reliable :notworthy: .

 

I must admit I did consider the Beretta Extrema but Im a lefty so not an option as Beretta dont accommodate.....

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have both a Benelli and a Winchester Super X3. I tend though to pick up the X3 first.

Both of mine are 3.5" so they can both handle any length of cartridge. They do however do them both in 3"?

The Benelli is Wetlands and the Super X3 is Mossy Oak Duck Blind. I believe that and Advantage Timber are the only two camo available in the X3?

 

 

4115490066_a64c436bf0.jpg

 

crecca

a nice pair of guns there. surely 2 is too many and you could sell me one :yes: lol, i will have a ring around tomorrow for the x3 as its a nice looking gun in the mossy oak duck blind. thanks for the input :thumbs:

 

ATB

Cal

Edited by olivhar01

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.

×